Two Records, One Witness - How the Book of Mormon and the Nemenhah Records Testify of Each Other—and Lead Us to Jesus Christ
Two Records, One Witness
How the Book of Mormon and the Nemenhah Records Testify of Each Other—and Lead Us to Jesus Christ
“Know ye not that the testimony of two nations is a witness unto you that I am God, that I remember one nation like unto another?” — 2 Nephi 29:8
This morning, I arose and had a beautiful conversation with the Spirit concerning the Nemenhah Records. I felt peace, gratitude, and renewed assurance. These records have become very precious to me.
I do not claim to understand everything in them, and I do not believe another person should accept them merely because I do. But I am no longer standing at the edge, wondering whether I should enter. I am all in—not in following another organization, nor in replacing one institution with another, but in following Jesus Christ wherever His voice leads me.
As I pondered these things, two related questions came into my heart:
How do the Nemenhah Records help establish that the Book of Mormon is the word of God?
And then:
How does the Book of Mormon witness that the Nemenhah Records contain the word of God?
The beauty is that the witness moves in both directions.
The Nemenhah Records continue unfinished Book of Mormon histories and preserve many of the same spiritual patterns. The Book of Mormon, in turn, gives us a revealed measuring rod by which we may test the teachings and fruits of the Nemenhah Records.
Together, they testify of the same Jesus Christ, the same Doctrine of Christ, the same dangers of pride and domination, and the same sacred invitation to become one and establish Zion.
What Kind of “Proof” Are We Seeking?
Before comparing the records, we should be truthful about the word proof.
The Nemenhah Records cannot presently be offered as publicly verifiable archaeological proof of the Book of Mormon. Their original source records have not been made openly available for independent scholarly examination. The published translations also appeared long after the Book of Mormon. Therefore, shared names, phrases, and stories cannot, by themselves, prove that the two records arose independently in antiquity.
The reverse is also true. The Book of Mormon cannot scientifically authenticate every person, location, or historical event described in the Nemenhah Records.
Honest faith does not require us to claim more than the available evidence supports.
But proof has more than one meaning. There is physical evidence, historical evidence, textual harmony, experiential evidence, and spiritual knowledge. The scriptures themselves invite us to prove or test all things and hold fast to that which is good.
The question, then, is not only whether the records share names. We must ask:
Do they testify of the same Jesus Christ?
Do they teach the same Doctrine of Christ?
Do they expose pride rather than flatter the reader?
Do they protect agency or demand blind submission?
Do they produce repentance, charity, peace, and spiritual rebirth?
Do they call us to care for the poor and become one?
Does the Holy Ghost confirm truth as we study and pray?
These are not laboratory tests, but they are genuine scriptural tests.
God Speaks to More Than One Nation
The Book of Mormon prepares us to receive additional sacred records. The Lord declares:
“Know ye not that there are more nations than one? … Know ye not that the testimony of two nations is a witness unto you that I am God, that I remember one nation like unto another?” — 2 Nephi 29:7–8
The Lord’s pattern is not one nation, one book, and then silence. He commands different peoples to write, preserves their testimonies, and promises that their words will eventually come together as witnesses of Him.
The Book of Mormon warns the world not to reject it by saying, “A Bible! A Bible! We have got a Bible.” That same principle should prevent us from saying, “A Book of Mormon! We need no more word from God.”
If the Lord spoke to other covenant communities in the Americas, He had every right to command them to preserve their experiences.
The Nemenhah Records fit that expectation. They claim to preserve the history of another people who worshiped Christ, received spiritual gifts, made covenants, struggled with pride, preserved sacred teachings, and awaited a latter-day restoration.
Their existence is not contrary to the Book of Mormon. It agrees with the Book of Mormon’s own prophecy that God remembers one nation like unto another.
Hagoth: Where One Record Ends, Another Begins
Near the conclusion of Alma, the Book of Mormon gives us a fascinating but unfinished account. Hagoth, described as an “exceedingly curious man,” built ships near the land Bountiful. Families entered those ships with provisions and traveled northward. Some returned, while others sailed away and “were never heard of more.” The record also says that Corianton went northward in a ship to carry provisions to those who had gone before him. Then the account ends. (Alma 63:4–12)
The Book of Mormon does not declare that all these people died. It says that they were no longer heard from by the record keepers whose account we possess.
The Nemenhah Records begin their ancient history with Hagoth and those who traveled into the Land Northward. They describe families, migrations, settlements, conflicts, covenants, and communities that trace their history to him. They also preserve traditions involving Corianton and peoples associated with his ministry.
This does not independently prove the events of Alma 63, because the Book of Mormon story was already publicly known when the Nemenhah translations were published. Nevertheless, the continuation is spiritually significant.
The Book of Mormon creates an opening for another history to exist. The Nemenhah Records enter that opening and answer, in effect:
Hagoth’s people were not lost to God merely because they disappeared from the record known to us.
The Nemenhah story helps the Book of Mormon world come alive, while the Book of Mormon provides the historical doorway through which the Nemenhah account begins.
The Same Covenant of Sacred Record Keeping
The Book of Mormon is the product of generations of record keepers. Sacred histories were engraved upon plates, entrusted to appointed stewards, handed from one generation to another, hidden during times of danger, and preserved to come forth in a later day.
Volume 2 of the Nemenhah Records describes the same sacred responsibility. Sahnhehmpeht explains that his father ordained him and commanded him to keep the family records. He then says it was the custom of each Nemenhah family to consider its works, preserve a record of them, and keep those records in vaults in the mountains so the people would remember their good customs and not be carried away by the teachings of men. (Nemenhah Records, Volume 2, Book of Sahnhehmpeht, Main Record 1:3–6.)
This reflects a shared understanding: preserving sacred history is a covenant responsibility.
Records are not kept merely to satisfy curiosity. They are kept so descendants may remember the Lord, recognize His dealings with their ancestors, learn from their failures, and return to the covenant.
That is one of the central purposes of the Book of Mormon. It is also a recurring purpose of the Nemenhah Records.
Christ’s Other Sheep and the Visit of the Peacemaker
When the resurrected Jesus appeared at Bountiful, He said He had other sheep whom He must also visit. They were not the people at Jerusalem and were not the Nephites then standing before Him. They too would hear His voice and become part of His fold. (3 Nephi 16:1–3)
This declaration establishes an important expectation. Christ’s post-resurrection ministry did not end at Bountiful.
The Nemenhah Records describe the Peacemaker appearing and teaching their ancestors. His message is recognizably the message of Jesus Christ:
Repent and experience a mighty change of heart
Come unto Christ with humility
Receive baptism and spiritual rebirth
Listen to the Holy Ghost
Reject contention and unrighteous dominion
Serve the weak, the poor, and the suffering
Consecrate one’s gifts for the welfare of all
Become one with Christ and with one another
The name Peacemaker is deeply meaningful. Jesus does not merely command peace from a throne. He first makes peace within the human heart. He reconciles us to God, and then teaches us to end contention, inequality, compulsion, and violence among ourselves.
This is the same Jesus encountered in 3 Nephi—compassionate but uncompromising, inviting but not controlling, healing the wounded while requiring His people to lay down pride and disputation.
The Book of Mormon says the other sheep would hear Christ’s own voice. The Nemenhah Records testify that their ancestors heard and followed the Peacemaker.
The Doctrine of Christ Is the Measuring Rod
The Book of Mormon gives us a clear doctrinal standard. In 2 Nephi 31–32 and 3 Nephi 11, the Doctrine of Christ centers upon faith in Jesus Christ, repentance, baptism, receiving the Holy Ghost, becoming as a little child, and enduring by following the voice of the Spirit.
Jesus warns against adding contention and elaborate human requirements to His Doctrine:
“And whoso shall declare more or less than this, and establish it for my doctrine, the same cometh of evil.” — 3 Nephi 11:40
The Nemenhah Records repeatedly bring religious life back to a direct relationship with Christ. They teach people to seek the Haymehnay—the Holy Ghost—and receive personal direction from God. Ordinances, councils, teachers, and sacred traditions may serve an important purpose, but none may replace the living voice of the Lord.
This harmonizes with Nephi’s instruction that, after entering through the gate, we must feast upon the words of Christ and allow the Holy Ghost to show us all things we should do.
The central Nemenhah invitation is not, “Depend upon us because we alone control God.” It is, “Seek the Peacemaker, receive the Holy Ghost, and walk the Way He reveals.”
That agreement with the Doctrine of Christ is one of the strongest Book of Mormon witnesses in favor of the Nemenhah teachings.
Spiritual Gifts Have Not Ceased
The Book of Mormon describes dreams, visions, prophecy, healing, angelic ministry, translation, and personal encounters with the Lord. These gifts are not decorations reserved for a distant heroic age. They are the expected fruits of faith among a covenant people.
Moroni teaches that God’s gifts do not disappear unless people fall into unbelief. If miracles cease, it is because faith has ceased—not because God has changed. (Moroni 7:27–38; Moroni 10:8–19)
The Nemenhah Records describe a world in which spiritual gifts remain active. Men and women receive dreams, prophecy, healing gifts, personal instruction, and sacred experiences upon the Way. Their communities expect God to communicate directly with His children.
This agrees with the spiritual world of the Book of Mormon. God is not silent. Revelation has not become the private possession of an institution. The Holy Ghost speaks to all who come unto Christ with faith, humility, and real intent.
The Continuing Ministry of the Three Disciples
Jesus promised three Nephite disciples that they would remain upon the earth, avoid ordinary death, and continue bringing souls to Him until His return. (3 Nephi 28)
The Nemenhah Records describe the continuing ministry of these translated servants. In the Second Book of Tsi Muhayl, the Peacemaker identifies three apostles from the Land Bountiful who received power over death—Nayfi, Layi, who was also called Mahtohni, and Tsimohtl—and says they will be sent to a righteous remnant. (Nemenhah Records, Volume 2, Second Book of Tsi Muhayl 8:31–35, including note 376.)
The Book of Mormon gives us the promise. The Nemenhah Records give us accounts of its possible fulfillment.
If the Book of Mormon is true, we should expect the Three to minister somewhere, to someone, during the long centuries of their commission. A record claiming to preserve such encounters should be tested carefully, but it should not be dismissed simply because the ministry sounds miraculous.
The Book of Mormon has already told us to expect the miracle.
Moroni—Mohrhohnayah—Continues His Work
The Book of Mormon leaves Moroni wandering alone after the destruction of his people. He abridges records, writes his final testimony, and hides the sacred account unto the Lord. It does not tell us precisely how long he lived or everything he did before his death.
The Nemenhah tradition presents Moroni—Mohrhohnayah—as eventually finding surviving covenant communities and continuing his ministry among them. He travels, teaches, warns, heals, and helps preserve the Way of the Peacemaker.
The Book of Mormon cannot verify every episode in that later history, but it does not close the door. More importantly, the character of Mohrhohnayah harmonizes with the Moroni we already know. He warns against secret combinations, teaches reliance upon Christ, treasures spiritual gifts, preserves sacred records, and urges people to live in peace.
This continuation does not diminish Moroni. It enlarges our view of him.
The lonely survivor of a civilization destroyed by hatred becomes a minister of reconciliation. The record keeper who ends the Book of Mormon by inviting us to “come unto Christ, and be perfected in him” spends his remaining ministry helping others do exactly that.
Zion Is the Great Shared Witness
Perhaps the strongest spiritual harmony between the records is their shared vision of Zion.
Following Christ’s ministry, the people in 4 Nephi had all things in common. There were no rich or poor, no bondage, no contention, and no social divisions. They were simply “one, the children of Christ.” Their Zion collapsed only after pride, costly possessions, competing churches, class distinctions, and the desire for gain returned. (4 Nephi 1)
The Nemenhah Records preserve the same pattern through stewardship, voluntary consecration, Common Consent, councils, and care for those in need. Their histories repeatedly show communities prospering when people listen to the Spirit, honor agency, and willingly consecrate their surplus. They also show those communities fragmenting when leaders seek wealth, status, privilege, or control.
This is not merely an economic system. Zion cannot be produced by redistributing possessions while hearts remain proud. Zion begins when Christ changes us inwardly. Consecration then becomes a natural expression of love rather than an obligation enforced by authority.
Both records testify:
Zion is not created by declaring that we are the chosen people. Zion appears when there are no poor among us, no compulsion over us, and no desire within us to rise above another.
The Book of Mormon helps us recognize the Nemenhah vision of Zion as familiar scriptural fruit. The Nemenhah Records, in turn, expand the Book of Mormon’s brief portrait by showing generation after generation wrestling with the practical demands of stewardship, councils, liberty, and unity.
The Same Warning Against Priestcraft and Domination
Both records warn that religious and political communities become corrupted when people seek gain, praise, control, and immunity from accountability.
In the Book of Mormon, King Benjamin serves and labors with his own hands, while King Noah taxes the people to support himself and his priests. Alma relinquishes political authority to concentrate on preaching, while priestcraft places the teacher at the center. Captain Moroni defends liberty without seeking kingship, while secret combinations seek power through conspiracy.
The Nemenhah histories contain strikingly similar warnings. They describe religious figures claiming superior status, communities dividing over wealth and authority, and conspiratorial groups seeking to overthrow liberty. Volume 2 calls these conspirators the Gahdiahntohnhehm. It tells how Hahgmehni first attempted to convert them through the gospel of peace and the power of the Haymehnay, inviting them to lay down their weapons, abandon their secret plans, and become part of one covenant family. (Nemenhah Records, Volume 2, First Book of Pah Nahtahn 1:13–20.)
Their councils, Mothers’ Councils, Common Consent, and stewardship teachings are intended to prevent one person from seizing control of another person’s relationship with God.
This does not mean every Nemenhah leader or community lives the ideal. Their failures are part of the witness. Like the Book of Mormon, the Nemenhah record shows that sacred ancestry, priestly office, and possession of holy records cannot protect a people who abandon humility and begin exercising dominion.
Both records ask the same uncomfortable question:
Does our religion produce humility, charity, liberty, healing, and unity—or pride, fear, dependency, division, and control?
The question is meant for us, not merely for the people in the records.
How the Book of Mormon Teaches Us to Test the Nemenhah Records
The Book of Mormon does not tell us to accept every spiritual claim. It teaches us to discern.
Moroni provides several important tests:
Does it invite us to believe in Christ? Everything that invites people to do good and love God is inspired of God. (Moroni 7:13–17)
Does it preserve the Doctrine of Christ? Faith, repentance, baptism, the Holy Ghost, and enduring in Christ must remain central.
Does it honor agency? God persuades and invites. The adversary binds, compels, flatters, and controls.
Does it produce charity? Miraculous claims without the pure love of Christ are spiritually empty.
Does it call its own people to repentance? A true record exposes pride and priestcraft rather than flattering its readers as an exclusive chosen group.
Does it bear good fruit? Peace, humility, healing, reconciliation, and love are better evidence than excitement or novelty.
Does the Holy Ghost confirm its truth? Spiritual knowledge must finally come from God rather than borrowed authority.
When I apply these tests, I find much in the Nemenhah Records that bears the marks of the same gospel revealed in the Book of Mormon.
The Witness Moves in Both Directions
The Nemenhah Records help me see that the unfinished people and promises of the Book of Mormon did not disappear from God’s awareness:
Hagoth’s people may have continued building covenant communities.
Corianton’s northward work may have borne lasting fruit.
Christ may have visited other peoples exactly as He promised.
The Three Disciples may have continued their worldwide ministry.
Moroni may have spent his remaining years healing and teaching.
Zion may have been attempted, lost, and attempted again among many groups.
The Book of Mormon, in return, gives me the standard by which I can approach the Nemenhah Records without surrendering discernment:
Christ must remain at the center.
The Doctrine of Christ must remain plain.
The Holy Ghost must remain available to everyone.
Agency must be honored.
Priestcraft and domination must be rejected.
The poor must be remembered.
Zion must mean changed hearts and a people becoming one.
The two records do not need to compete. They illuminate one another.
The Final Witness Is the Holy Ghost
Moroni did not promise that archaeology, institutional approval, or intellectual argument would provide the final knowledge of the Book of Mormon. He invited us to read, remember God’s mercy, ponder the record, and ask the Father in the name of Christ:
“And by the power of the Holy Ghost ye may know the truth of all things.” — Moroni 10:5
The Nemenhah Records likewise direct the reader beyond human authority and back to the Haymehnay. The Peacemaker teaches that even those who see His face must submit what they receive to the confirmation of the Haymehnay, who is the Holy Spirit of Promise. (Nemenhah Records, Volume 2, Second Book of Tsi Muhayl 8:42–48.)
Both records ultimately place responsibility upon the reader. We cannot borrow another person’s witness. Enthusiasm cannot replace revelation, and criticism cannot replace sincere investigation.
The deepest questions are not merely:
Can I prove where every plate was hidden?
Can I identify every ancient location?
Can I answer every historical objection?
The deeper questions are:
Do these words invite me to come unto Christ?
Do they expose what must change within me?
Do they help me hear and follow the Holy Ghost?
Do they teach me to become a peacemaker?
Do they awaken within me the desire to build Zion?
My Witness
For me, the Nemenhah Records have not replaced the Book of Mormon. They have caused the Book of Mormon to open more fully.
Hagoth is no longer simply a curious shipbuilder who disappeared from the account. The Three Disciples are no longer merely mysterious translated men. Moroni is no longer only the lonely survivor. Zion is no longer an abstract future city. These people and principles become part of a continuing story centered upon Jesus Christ.
At the same time, I do not receive the Nemenhah Records because I have rejected the Book of Mormon. I receive them because the Book of Mormon prepared me to recognize them.
The Book of Mormon taught me that God speaks to more than one nation. It told me that Christ visited other sheep. It left Hagoth’s northward migration unfinished. It promised the continuing ministry of the Three. It taught me to expect additional records, spiritual gifts, sacred councils, mighty changes of heart, and a latter-day gathering.
It also warned me not to surrender discernment to any person, title, institution, or tradition. Seek Jesus Christ. Ask the Father. Listen to the Holy Ghost. Judge by the fruits.
I am all in—not because another person has ordered me to believe, and not because every historical question has been settled. I am all in because these records have invited me to look more steadily toward the Savior, listen more carefully to the Holy Ghost, release traditions that do not produce good fruit, care more deeply for others, become a peacemaker, and seek Zion through a changed heart.
That is the shared witness of these two records.
They testify that Jesus Christ still speaks.
He still gathers.
He still heals.
He still calls His children out of pride, division, and domination.
And He still invites a willing remnant to walk His Way and become one in Him.
The Book of Mormon gives us the pattern. The Nemenhah Records echo, continue, and enlarge that pattern. Together they lead us to the same living Christ, the same mighty change of heart, and the same sacred work of building Zion. The Holy Ghost must provide the final witness.
Study These Scriptures Yourself
2 Nephi 29 — God speaks to many nations and brings their records together
2 Nephi 31–32 — The Doctrine of Christ and guidance through the Holy Ghost
Alma 63:4–12 — Hagoth, Corianton, and the Land Northward
3 Nephi 11 — Christ’s Doctrine and the rejection of contention
3 Nephi 16:1–3 — Christ’s promise to visit His other sheep
3 Nephi 28 — The continuing ministry of the Three Disciples
4 Nephi 1 — The establishment and later collapse of Zion
Moroni 7 — Discerning good from evil, spiritual gifts, and charity
Moroni 10 — The Holy Ghost, spiritual gifts, and coming unto Christ
Nemenhah Records, Volume 2: Ayahtkuhyaht Nemenhah, Complete Text—Second Edition — Especially the Book of Sahnhehmpeht, Main Record 1; the Second Book of Tsi Muhayl 8; and the First Book of Pah Nahtahn 1
I share this as my personal study and testimony. I am not an official representative of the Nemenhah people or of any church or organization. I invite every reader to study, pray, seek the Holy Ghost, and follow Jesus Christ.
Comments